Court orders prisoner computers – South Africa
Media Release, 25 November 2024
“We welcome the judgment of the South African Constitutional Court in the Ntuli case, which ordered correctional facilities to allow prisoners access to computers in cells for educational purposes. The total ban by Corrections, and their arguments about security concerns, were swept aside by the Court. Research shows a third reduction in recidivism amongst prisoners who have had access to education” said CJC President Mr John Dowd AO KC.
“The recognition of this right in South Africa highlights the parlous state of education delivery to Australian detainees. Technological advancements in the community have disadvantaged prisoner education, as hard copy tertiary correspondence courses available ten years ago have been replaced by online services which require access to computers. There are obvious benefits in enabling prisoners to continue their studies in-cell. Computers in cells with access to approved mainstream services would also enable effective counselling without conflicts of interest and provide continuity upon their release” said Vice President Ms Elizabeth Evatt AC.
“The CJC proposes these recommendations for Australian corrections” said Mr Dowd.
- There must be open access to diverse courses run by educational institutions for people in prison. This would require improved access to computers in cells, hardware such as keyboards and monitors to facilitate APPROVED studies, and relevant software and access to educational institutions’ white-listed websites.
- In the interim, prisoners should be allowed to purchase books directly from Australia’s largest bookseller, Dymocks. This may be facilitated by the Australasian Correctional Education Association, who might create a list of suitable reading materials, subjects, and prospects for employment. Such processes would promote self-directed learning and allow prisons access to education immediately, before technology is universally available.
- All prisoners should have the support of a welcoming and adequately trained ‘Education Officer’. This will ensure prisoners are made aware of education opportunities, as well as requirements for course completion both within incarceration and beyond.
As per the second recommendation, Justice Action has compiled the following list of career prospects for prisoners to undertake post-release. We have also listed some resources that we are fighting to be obtainable during incarceration, such as textbooks.
1. Agriculture / horticulture
- Book: Basics of farming
- Book: Principles of Horticulture
2. Building and construction / Heavy machinery / Traffic control
- Curtin University: Bachelor of Applied Science (Construction Management)
- Curtin University: Graduate Certificate in Project Management
- Majority of parolees take up post-release employment in the construction industry (84%) – labouring (50% of all jobs), technician and trade, machinery operation and driving.
- Book: Basic Building and Construction Skills
- Book: Construction Skills
- “Attitudes towards the employment of ex-offenders in construction are significantly more positive than in other industries. 30.9% of sub-contractors had hired ex-offenders previously; 30.9% of sub-contractors had not hired ex-offenders previously but were willing to do so.” (Source: Professor Martin Loosemore, UTS fact sheet “Integrating ex-offenders into the Australian construction industry”)
3. Business owner
- Curtin University: Undergraduate Certificate in Business Administration (can be credited to Bachelor of Commerce).
- Book: Quit Your Job Own a Business: The Journey From Employee to Business Owner
- Book: P&C Business Strategic Management: A Competitive Advantage Approach
- Book: Data Insights and Financial Performance
4. Chef
- AMC has opened a bakery and people working there can obtain a Certificate II in Retail Bakery Assistant.
- Book: Professional Chef Commercial Cookery With Online Study Tools
- Book: Professional Chef: Kitchen Operations With Online Study Tools
- Book: Australia Fish & Seafood Cookbook
5. Disability support and care
- Persons charged with serious offences will not be eligible to work for NDIS.
- Book: The Road to Social Work and Human Service Practice
- Book: Human Rights and Social Work
6. Independent contractor or freelancer
- If an individual has expertise in specific fields
- Freelancer: copywriter, editor, website builder, and more
- Independent contractor: carpenter, auto repair, plumber
- Book: John Wiley & Sons Advertising
7. Information Technology
- Computer coding
- Increasingly relevant skill in the digitised world
- Curtin University: Bachelor of Computing (Major: Computer Science)
- The well-established “Simply Coding” organisation in the US delivers programs that may be useful for coding education in Aus prisons(https://simplycoding.org)
- Dymocks has wide range of available books
- Book: Computer Systems: A Programmers Perspective
- Book: Coding: Coding Basics
- Book: First Coding: Debugging Code
- “The restricted access [prisoners] have to [ICT] is a form of censure that renders them second-class citizens in the Information Age” (Aysher Kerr, Matthew Willis ‘Prisoners use of information and communications technology’).
- Artificial Intelligence
- Book: Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach
- Book: Natural Language Processing with Python
8. Language
- English as a second language (ESL)
- Learning English is essential for integration back into society, obtaining a high-skilled job
- Lack of language support can also create additional hurdles to accessing services and information within prisons.
- Book: McGraw-Hills Essential ESL Grammar
- Book: Perfect Phrases ESL Everyday Business
9. Law
- Important to understand their own rights as well as prisoners
- Can be accessed through education providers like School locker (if prisoners have access to education providers in the first place
- Dymocks: has multiple books about criminal and constitutional law
- Book: Constitutional Rights of Prisoners
- Book: Criminal Law in Australia, LexisNexis Criminal Law in Australia
- Book: Crime, Criminality and Criminal Justice
- Book: Crime and Justice
- Book: Human Rights and Social Work
- Book: Foundations in Australian Law
- Book: Principles of Criminal Law
- Book: Crime Prevention
- Book: LexisNexis Concise Australian Legal Dictionary
- Book: Criminal Procedure in Australia
10. Mental Health
- Curtin University: INDH2006 Indigenous Mental Health
- Curtin University: MENT2000 Common Mental Health Disorders
- Curtin University: Undergraduate Certificate in Indigenous Mental Health
- University of Southern Queensland: TPP0175 Introduction to Psychology & Counselling
- Book: Psychology – Australian and New Zealand Edition
- Book: Breaking Negative Thinking Patterns
- Book: An Introduction to Counselling and Psychotherapy
- Book: Mental Health Care
- Peer Mentoring
- Book: Practical Exercises for Mental Health Professionals
- Book: Peer Support in Mental Health
- Book: Peer work in Australia
- Tafe offers a Certificate IV in Mental Health Peer Work (Consumer Peer Work)
11. Music
- Book: Music Theory for Dummies
- Book: Music and Musicians
12. Physical education and fitness training
- Curtin University: Undergraduate Certificate in Health Science (can be credited to Bachelor of Health Science).
- Book: Essential Guide to Fitness
- Book: Science of Strength Training
13. Sociology
- Curtin University: Bachelor of Arts (Sociology & Anthropology)
- Book: Sociologic
- Book: Pearson Education: Sociology
14. Trades
- Book: Basic Plumbing Skills
- TAFE offers vocational training e.g. Certificate II in construction, furniture making, horticulture
15. Visual art
- Curtin University: Bachelor of Arts (Fine Arts)
- Curtin University JETA Program
- Art curation
- Curtin University: Bachelor of Visual Arts (Curation, Innovation, Visual Art)
- Book: The Curator’s Handbook
- Book: Curating Art Now